
Alejandra Guajardo, Staff Development Team Leader – SIL Americas
I have served as a facilitator in the Spanish online mentoring course for the Americas area for the past three years. This course was originally developed by Elke Muller in English, as an intensive 2-week in-person workshop. The arrival of the pandemic forced us to develop a more condensed online 20-hour version. This adapted course has been taken by almost 50 people, including translation and literacy consultants (experienced consultants and consultants-in-training), as well as staff and team leaders from other departments (HR, technology, training, etc.). The diversity of the participants (age, nationality, language, cultural and academic background) is a challenge for the facilitators, but this diversity has made the learning experience rich and profound. In reviewing the participant reflections in the forums and activities of the course, I have identified some important take-aways.
1. It is necessary to know yourself well before starting a mentoring relationship
Before starting the mentoring relationship, it is essential that both the mentor and the mentee consciously (and strategically) carry out a series of necessary steps, including a self-assessment for self-knowledge. As adults, we could assume that we know ourselves quite well; however, there will always be aspects of our personality that we are cognisant of. These could present a challenge in the mentoring relationship.
- Am I an introvert or extrovert?
- When making a decision, do I give more importance to facts, objectivity and data, or do I think that the most important consideration is the person?
- Do I learn best about a topic by listening to personal stories and discovering how people apply their learning in real life, or do I prefer concrete information (data, analysis and examples) that I may apply in a practical way?
- Is my communication style direct or indirect?
- When my mentor gives me feedback, do I prefer the mentor to get straight to the point and tell me where I went wrong, or does that kind of direct feedback make me feel bad?

Picture: Kaiwá Bible translator Salvador Sanches (right) and Brazilian translation consultant Cristiano Barros (left) working together. Salvador drafted the translation alone and then he and Cristiano revised it and continued the work together. Photo: Wycliffe Global Alliance
2. Have an initial conversation to clarify roles, expectations and beliefs.
One of our participants shared in a forum,“I ask myself as a mentor: If I don’t know the other person’s expectations, their goals, their needs, their strengths and weaknesses, will I be able to effectively guide and support my mentee? Can we agree and move forward on a proper path to success?”
Being clear about what role each person will have in the mentoring relationship will allow us to move forward more easily and quickly to achieve the learning goals. In addition, sharing our expectations and beliefs about what mentoring is and what we think a mentor and a mentee should do will save us a lot of headache. It will prevent us from falling into disappointment and apathy when we find that this is not what I expected.
In my experience working on the mentoring project in the Americas, I have seen cases in which problems between mentor and mentee could have been avoided (or resolved) more easily if both had talked about these points before starting the mentoring process:
- A mentee treated his mentor like a therapist, each meeting sharing all his personal problems and existential doubts. The mentor felt uncomfortable and overwhelmed with the situation.
- A mentee complained bitterly because her mentor wanted to control every aspect of her life, going beyond the growth goals that the mentee wanted to achieve (developing as a translation consultant) and even trying to impose a daily schedule of tasks (that were totally incompatible with her personal life and responsibilities).
3. Try to know and understand the context and culture of the other person.
As members of a multicultural organization, we may think that our knowledge about cultural differences and their impact on our relationships is sufficient; however, we need to ensure that we do not fall into stereotypes or generalisations that lead to misunderstanding. We must approach our mentoring partner with respect, humility, and with a genuine interest towards their personal history, context, and culture. In the words of one of our participants from Colombia, “As a mentor I think that appreciating the differences is very important. We can find a lot of richness in the diversity of thoughts and perspectives on a topic or learning. Also, one can discover things that one would never have considered before.”

Picture: Translation consultant, Gisela Beckman talking with a consultant in training during a translation consultant workshop in Lima, Peru ( March 2023) Photo:Mauro Micieli
Ideally before starting a mentoring relationship, we should take the time to get to know each other better, clarify doubts, and reflect on our personal learning styles. Unfortunately, many times this does not happen. It may be that our enthusiasm to begin this learning experience is too great. In other cases, especially when it is a formal mentoring program, there may be pressure from our supervisors to find a mentor or perhaps there is a shortage of mentors available and we will be assigned the person who is closest to us.
So, if you are thinking about starting a mentoring process (either as a mentor or mentee), start your preparation now and try to take the time to talk with your future mentoring partner about these issues. Look for similarities and shared interests, and pray to the Lord together for help to grow in knowledge and respect about your differences. If you are the supervisor of someone who is going to begin this experience, make sure that he or she has the time and resources necessary to begin well.
4. The same formula doesn’t always work. It will depend on the context.
In one of the last activities of the mentoring course, we ask our participants to reflect on the different types of mentoring that exist (formal, informal, group, individual, peer, etc.) and determine if all of these types are possible in their cultural and organizational contexts. It is interesting to see that while everyone appreciates the advantages of formal mentoring (establishing clear goals, a development plan, signing a mentoring agreement, etc.), participants recognized that it is not always possible or effective to establish a formal program and that some flexibility is necessary.
“It may not be easy to implement it in such a formal way, I think each stage could be gradually integrated. Labeling is not a custom in Latin America. Here, the processes occur naturally, they flow naturally. When have you seen a Peruvian or Colombian follow the instructions in a cookbook to make a dish?… Never. Well, the same would be with mentoring.”

Picture: A session on group mentoring during a translation consultant workshop in Lima, Peru ( March 2023) Photo: Mauro Micieli
It may also be the case that in many contexts, individual mentoring is the most successful. A mentor walks with their mentee in their development, devoting significant time and interest to them.
However in other situations, it is group-mentoring that will give better results.
“In our indigenous reality, it is much easier to walk with another person and transmit knowledge through practice. Well, we are communitarian, we learn in groups, in community, seeing, hearing, experiencing.”
In other cases, team-mentoring or peer-mentoring would be the most effective option.
“I think that in our field a Community of Practice would work better. It is wonderful to imagine that literacy consultants could meet regularly to encourage each other in taking on apprentices and passing on their knowledge. I could imagine a planned group mentoring on a specific topic in which the consultant with the most experience in that topic could teach all the trainees.”
Therefore, if you are a mentor or team leader thinking about starting a mentoring program, consider what type of mentoring would work in your context and culture. Does your organization or team have the right structure for the type of mentoring you have chosen? Is it possible to implement in-person mentoring, or is online mentoring is the only viable option? Perhaps it is possible to implement a hybrid system that adjusts to the reality of the context and individual and cultural preferences? Whatever type of mentoring you choose, it should be a program that is flexible enough to take into account cultural values, organizational values, and personal preferences.
Share your ideas and insights below by clicking on “Leave a reply”.
















